Note: If you click a link on this page, then go on to make a purchase, we may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you.
What kind of smoker would be best suited to your needs, an electric smoker vs pellet smoker? It mostly depends on taste or convenience, in my opinion. There’s more. You can shop for the best smoker keeping in mind the initial cost of purchasing, ongoing costs, as well as reliability.
Having trouble deciding on what kind of smoker to buy?
The Difference Between An Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker
Various types of smokers are available, each with its unique benefits and features.
What Is an Electric Smoker?
An electric heating element provides the necessary heat for smoking at the bottom of the box. Over there are usually two smaller boxes – one for wood chips and one for water.
In an electric smoker, you can start the cooking process with the push of a button. You can either use an analog or digital control. You need to press the button to start the smoker. Unlike the digital version, the analog version includes a rotary dial for temperature adjustments.
How Does An Electric Smoker Work?
An electric smoker uses electricity for power, just as pellet smokers do. However, an electric smoker also uses that electricity to heat your food.
A rheostat or a thermostat controls the electricity in these smokers. Units with thermostats are usually more expensive since they allow for better temperature control. The coil is heated and smolder (usually wood chips placed in a metal bowl). Smoke is produced when the wood smolders, which enhances the flavor of your food.
The tray above your electric smoker needs to be filled with wood chips before it is turned on. Turn on the water pan after adding water. Rods in the firebox heat up and burn wood chips, which produces smoke and heats the unit. By keeping the water tray cold, you can prevent overheating, create steam, and maintain moisture.
What Makes Electric Smokers Popular
One of the main reasons electric smokers are so popular is that they allow them to cook without any hassle. Maintaining heat level using it does not require much effort. It is automatically balanced.
Additionally, there is no need to stuff fuel inside to get a fire going, as in offset smokers. When you plug in and set the temperature, you’re good to go.A smoker powered by electricity is also reasonably easy to operate. Almost anyone can use it.
Here are some things we like in Electric Smoker:
Smokers that use electric power perform well at low temperatures. An electric smoker is the most convenient way to smoke things like cheese, fish, and sausages.
Electric smokers can cook a large amount of food with little space required since they come in upright shapes. A power outlet and wood chips are all you need for electric smokers.
We don’t like these things about electric smokers:
The number of ways you can treat meat with an electric smoker is also limited. Smoking meat is possible at low to mid-range temperatures.
Your electric smoker uses wood chips, but the taste is nothing like what you get from cooking over the fire.
What Is a Pellet Smoker?
The pellet smoker is an outdoor cooker that combines the qualities of a smoker, charcoal grill, gas grill, and oven and uses 100% natural food-grade hardwood pellets. Country Smokers are powered by hardwood pellets, which achieve indirect heat (meaning food is not cooked directly over a flame, but rather by the radiant heat circulating throughout).
Smoking with Pellets – How Does it Work?
In a wood pellet plant, wood pellets are stored in hoppers. Using an electric auger (a rotating device that looks like a drill bit), pellets are fed into the burn pot. Once ignited, the wood pellets produce a maintained flame as more pellets are dropped into the burn pot. A temperature controller does control this feed. Increasing the setting will lead to a faster feed time. The air in the smoker comes from intake fans that circulate heat and smoke.
What makes pellet smokers so popular?
Pellet smokers are so cool (and so popular) because they let you enjoy 100% wood-smoked meats without having to figure out how to use a problematic offset smoker.
Which pellet grills do we prefer?
The fuel used in pellet smokers is natural wood, so you’ll always get that distinctive wood-fired flavor.
It’s hard to find a more convenient source of natural fuel than wood pellets. Smokers using pellets don’t require babysitting or hours of preparation like traditional smokers. Smoking is a “set and forgets” activity for them.
However, pellet smokers can do much more than simply smoke meat. Pellet smokers work much like grills.
Among the drawbacks of smoking pellets are:
Higher price for entry-level models, but you get a functional product that can last for years – there is no such thing as a cheap model.
Pellet smokers need electricity to run, even if the heat comes from wood pellets. For this reason, you will need an outlet nearby whenever you use the smoker.
Comparison Table Between Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker
|Electric Smoker||Pellet Smoker|
|Type of cooking||Smoking||Smoking, baking, roasting, and grilling|
|Cooking capacity||Small to very large||Small to large|
|Price range (USD)||$150-$600+||$500-$2,000+|
|Fuel type||Electric with smoke created from heating wood chips||100% wood pellets with an electric powered motor|
Let’s break down a few factors that differentiate these two types of smokers.
Pellet vs Electric Smokers – Getting Started
You can smoke meats with electric smokers by pushing just a button. Electric smokers are powered by electricity. As the smoker slowly cooks the meat to the desired temperature, wood is placed over the internal heating rod. Connect pellet smokers to an outlet so they can keep cooking meat since these devices don’t rely heavily on electricity.
Instead, they operate like a traditional grill using pellet fuel. To smoke pellets, the heater rod moves the pellets from the hopper to the firepot. You can smoke the meat according to your personal preferences by using the convection heating system.
Electric Smoker vs Pellet Grills – Controls
Depending on the model, the device interface will most likely be digital. Another possibility is that your controls are analog. With either type of display, learning and using the device will be simple. It takes only a few seconds to set your temperature, insert your meat, and let the timer run.
Using pellet smokers, you may adjust the temperature while your meats cook with the simple turn of a dial. For precise temperature control, you’re unlikely to have a rheostat or thermostat. Pellet smokers can be adjusted to your preferred temperature. On these machines, there is no timer. You will have to monitor to make sure everything is cooked to perfection closely.
Heat & Smoke Sources for Meat Flavor
Rich and smoky flavors make pellet smokers popular. Smoking sessions provide you with the taste you desire, powered by wood pellets that can completely alter the taste of the meat.
Each dinner becomes an adventure when you cook with wood pellets. Due to close contact with the pellets, pellet smokers produce a lot more smoke and flavor. By using this device, you will be able to cook meats that no other device can.
The flavor of an electric smoker is similar to that of an authentic charcoal unit. With its direct wood-fired heat, this soup tastes vastly different from your average homemade soup grill at a faster rate. However, the flavor comes mainly from the heat rather than entirely from wood. An electric grill is not as rich as the taste offered by pellet smokers.
Pellet Grills vs Electric Smokers – Operational Costs
Cost is a significant difference between the two devices. You will pay a different price for the initial purchase and operate it in electric and pellet machines.
An electric smoker can be operated by plugging it into an outlet and preparing 6-8 ounces of wood. Electricity costs will be a little higher, but not by much. Because you won’t need much wood, you can buy it in bulk and store it near your machine.
Additionally, buying an electric smoker is more affordable from a retailer. A basic model costs just under $100. Even though pellet-powered machines are more complicated internally than these machines, their cost is much lower than those powered by pellets.
Even though the pellet will rely on electricity, it will use more wood than electric power. Cook in high quantities can’t be done without stocking up on pellets.
The rate at which you need to smoke is 1-2 lbs an hour. You will likely burn through more pellets than you would expect at first because this type of cooking relies on slow and low cooking. Additionally, the cost of purchasing pellets is higher. A basic model will cost you at least $500.
Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker: What’s the Same?
From these setup, controls, and tastes, it’s easy to see how electric or pellet could completely change the way you grill your meats.
Is there any similarity between the two?
Pellet vs Electric Smokers – Performance
The great thing about both smokers is that they cook meat at a low temperature for a long time, producing tasty meat.
Whether you choose an electric or pellet model won’t make a difference in how long it lasts. You don’t have to worry about either of these smokers with a longer lifespan; they are both built to last.
Pellet vs Electric Smokers – Health Benefits
Both types of smokers do not use gas or charcoal, so they are much healthier to use. The meat is cooked indirectly, which means your dinner will not absorb harmful chemicals. Electric vs. pellet doesn’t matter when it comes to health: avoiding gas and charcoal will prevent skin and respiratory problems down the road.
Conclusions on Electric Smokers Vs Pellet Smokers
As a whole, an electric smoker is a convenient and budget-friendly option. Cooking delicious food is possible in many environments. You won’t get the smokiness that a charcoal grill can produce, but it’s still an improvement.
If you’re looking for a deep flavor, a pellet smoker is perfect for you. The electric option is more convenient and more affordable. Nevertheless, the taste is unmatched, so those factors do not matter as much.